Vogel's Collision

Public ratings

Ratings snapshots collected 2026-05-15. Full review text is published by the original platforms — we link rather than republish.

About (editorial)

Vogel's Collision has operated continuously since 1948, when founder Henry Vogel opened the original shop. Long-time employee Barry Holtz, who had worked at the shop since 1968, purchased the business from Henry in 1993 and continues to run it today — an employee-to-owner transition that is rare in the body-shop trade and signals deep institutional continuity. The shop describes itself as i-Car Gold and ASE certified and stands behind every repair with a lifetime workmanship warranty for as long as the customer owns the vehicle. The Winton Road North location sits at the Brighton/Penfield corridor edge, with hours 7:30am to 5pm weekdays. For Brighton and Penfield customers who want a multi-decade-tenured independent rather than a dealer collision center, this is the canonical answer.

77 years of continuous operation under two owner generations — the longest-tenured independent body shop on this list. I-CAR Gold Class is owner-claimed and not independently verified via the goldclass.i-car.com locator.